BrushMcCoy.com Forum

[jason060]

I would like to open a discussion about valuation and damages or imperfections if you will. Yes, I know, beauty is in the eye of the beholder but we all want a realistic idea of value when buying or selling ceramics and want the best we can afford given the condition. When you see a valuation in a price guide, does this mean only pristene? Does a "fleabite" count? What does it mean when they give a range of prices? In general terms, how does an excellent chip repair affect valuation as oppossed to a bad one or none? Crazing!! Many old pots and vases have crazing, inside or out. Are there any refence materials that would help? Please don't say it's all subjective, I'm sure hard-bitten evaluators have some definate ideas on the subject. Thanks for any input.

[mike]

[jason060]

Thanks so much for taking the time to answer my questions so concisely.

I get your distinctions about rare, hard to find and common, very helpful. I'm relieved to hear crazing isn't a deal-killer and about stained crazing. You are pretty tough. I would accept a small chip on the bottom (understandible), definitely none on the rim. Like you, no cracks or repairs. I take a fleabite is a chip so small it probably has to be pointed out to you. I guess some folks go over it with a magnifying glass and blacklight.

I will assume the premise we all deplore deception and repair fraud. I just thought maybe an honest, excellent repair would preferred over leaving a valuable piece unrepaired, conservably speaking?? Like repairing an old painting.

I'm glad to hear from a very experienced collector. I might think a usual dealer will accept whatever condition leaves enough profit margin to resell. Please jump in you other folks... I'm sure there are other aspects and opinions to hear.

Jason